Getting Back in the Game
It has been a while since I cooked a brisket so I thought I would make my comeback with an experimental bang. Recently, I have been cooking a lot of beef BBQ because it is easy on the High-Blood Pressure versus pork. However, beef is a little less forgiving than pork and cooking it to perfection requires good recipes, good techniques and a good amount of patience.
Getting it Ready
So, I went to my favorite neighborhood butcher whom I will not name until they decide to pay me for shameless plugs that will boost their business. The brisket weighed in at 10.94 lbs. and is a very nice cut. I began by trimming the fat in the traditional manner. You can check one of my favorite BBQ forum sites for instructions that I refer to frequently: Prepping A Brisket.
After the trimming was done I pulled my Twice-Rubbed trick. First, I hand-massaged a mixture of salt, pepper, onion powder and garlic powder onto the brisket very liberally – easy on the salt though because you don’t want the crust to be too salty. Then I coated the brisket with my favorite yellow mustard. This is what we call a mustard slather and it is typically applied before any seasoning is applied. After the brisket was slathered with the yellow mustard, I them applied my favorite BBQ dry rub very liberally until the brisket was completely covered. Then, into the fridge for a chillin’ until time to go onto the smoker.
Firing Up the Smoker
I always cook my briskets on one of my WSMs (Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker). So I loaded her up with Royal Oak lump charcoal. I find that lump give meat a natural and clean flavor versus briquettes, but please… let us not get into that holy war right now!
Next, I put on a mix of hickory and oak chunks for smoke wood. I put the meat on the smoker as soon as I fired it up; I did not wait for the smoker to get up to 220* first. I like for the meat to smoke as long as possible before it gets to warm. This is very helpful to the smoke ring – especially using lump charcoal – in my experience.
The Cook
The meat went on the smoker at midnight exactly. I inserted the temperature probe and the meat was not as cold as I would liked it to have been. It read 51* and I usually like to see it start off between 38-41*. For me, that means a minimal smoke ring if any at all when cooking with lump. Oh well, on with the cook.
The temperature of the WSM stabilized around 1:00a and I watched a movie, posted on twitter and went to bed. Yeah, that’s right – the WSM is pretty much set it and forget! I love my WSMs. I woke up about 8:00a and the brisket was at 165* and I am cooking this one to 195*. The smoker temp was rock steady all night long between 225-230*.
At 10:30a the meat temperature was 175* – stubborn brisket! Anyway, that meant that this baby would cook for 12+ hours. No worries though; with the WSM, I don’t have to add more fuel until maybe around the 18 hour mark. I don’t use water in the WSM water pan so this cook can just roll on until its done – unattended.
1:00p – Finally! 195* and ready to come off the smoker. Sometimes I take the brisket off at 170*, wrap in foil and then let is finish cooking to 195*; but not this time. I wanted this one cook all the way done without foiling until after it was finished. So, that’s what I did; I wrapped in foil and put it in my meat warmer until serving time.
The Results
Sorry, I just took a quick break to get another taste of the brisket! lol!
Ok, back to work! This brisket had a very nice bark and the flavor was incredible. It was a good idea to go easy on the salt in the first layer of rub because I could definitely taste the spices I applied in that first round of seasoning. This was the tastiest bark I have ever had on a piece of BBQ.

The meat was very tender and retained some juiciness but no where near what I really like. Still it was a very flavorful brisket that I would not be ashamed to turn in at a competition if I had to. Overall, I am very happy with the results and will do the same thing again except I will foil at 170* and see if I can get it a bit juicier. Anyway, here are the finishing shots – enjoy!


Oh – by the way, Big-A is me. That was my street name back in the day and some of you may even remember it!